The Puzzle of India’s Persistent Motion
The collision of India with Asia stands as one of the most dramatic tectonic events of the Cenozoic era. This massive continental clash, which began around 50 million years ago, gave rise to the majestic Himalayas and the vast Tibetan Plateau. Yet long after the initial impact, India continued its northward march, seemingly defying conventional wisdom about plate tectonics.
Snapshots of India-Asia collision and the Indian plate velocity throughout Cenozoic.
As geodynamicists, we were intrigued by this persistent motion. What force could be strong and durable enough to keep pushing India northward, overcoming the enormous resistance generated by the thickened crust beneath Tibet for so long? Traditional explanations like slab pull and ridge push fell short, unable to account for either the long duration or the magnitude of the forces required.
To tackle this puzzle, we turned to quantitative global geodynamic modeling. This approach allowed us to simulate the entire Earth’s mantle dynamics over hundreds of millions of years, providing a comprehensive view of the forces at play. Our model was unique in its incorporation of a time-dependent, data-assimilation technique that allowed us to reconstruct the history of mantle flow and plate motions.
The Surprising Discovery: Mantle Wind
As we analyzed our model results, an unexpected player emerged: a powerful “mantle wind.” This deep Earth current, flowing faster than the overlying plate, exerts a dragging force on the base of the Indian lithosphere. The magnitude of this mantle drag is surprisingly large – comparable to slab pull, long considered the primary driver of plate tectonics but apparently lacking in the Tibet-Asia collision system. Crucially, this force matches estimates of what’s needed to raise the Tibetan Plateau, providing a missing piece in the puzzle of continental collision dynamics.
Two types of mantle drag and the resistance from India-Asia collision boundary.
But what causes this mantle wind? Our simulations revealed a complex interplay of factors. The sinking of the detached Neo-Tethyan slab and the massive accumulation of subducted material beneath East Asia create a lateral pressure gradient in the upper mantle. This gradient drives a northward flow, much like the wind in the atmosphere moving from high to low pressure areas.
Dynamic pressure and slab structure showing the deep earth dynamic system.
The Role of India’s Cratonic Root
A crucial element in this story is India’s thick cratonic root. Like a deep keel beneath a ship, this ancient, cold, and strong part of the lithosphere extends far into the mantle. We found that this root acts as a lever, amplifying the effect of the mantle drag on the entire Indian plate.
The interaction between the fast-flowing asthenosphere and the cratonic root creates a concentration of both frictional and pressure drag forces on the edge of the Indian continent. This mechanism explains how a relatively weak asthenosphere can still exert a significant influence on the motion of the overlying continent.
Why does the craton root matter?
Implications and Challenges
Our findings reshape our understanding of plate tectonics and continental collisions. The mantle wind we identified is part of a larger, hemispheric scale convergent flow pattern centered on Asia, right below the Tibetan Plateau. This pattern potentially explains a diverse range of regional phenomena: East Asian slab dynamics, western Pacific back-arc basin formation, and Australia’s rapid northward motion.
Â
The hemispheric scale convergence.
Arriving at these conclusions wasn’t without challenges. One major hurdle was quantifying the mantle drag force. Previous studies had often dismissed this force due to the low viscosity of the asthenosphere. Our breakthrough reveals that the maximum shear stress occurs within the strong lithospheric root, not in the weak asthenosphere below. This also emphasizes the importance of quantitative analysis in geodynamics research.
Throughout our research, we were continually surprised by the interconnectedness of Earth’s dynamic systems. What began as an investigation into the India-Asia collision led us to uncover a hemispheric scale mantle flow pattern that drives the closure of the Tethyan belt and potentially setting the stage for the next supercontinent. Our findings underscore the importance of considering the entire mantle system when studying regional tectonic processes. As we continue to refine our models and gather more data, we may uncover even more surprising connections between deep Earth dynamics and the geological features we see on the surface.