Quantifying the conductivity of a single polyene chain by lifting with an STM tip

Surface synthesis and lifting-up processFigure 1a illustrates the synthetic pathway of the target molecular chain 2. Molecules of 2 were formed on Cu(110) via a cascade dehydrogenation of octadecyl benzene, followed by the intermolecular-coupling. The introducing of phenyl groups effectively reduces the activation energy for breaking CH bond, facilitating the dehydrogenation of octadecyl benzene at 400 K over Cu(110) (Supplementary Fig. 1 and Supplementary Notes 1). Further annealing at 473 K resulted in the trans-intercoupling of phenyl [18] conjugated polyene (1), leading to the all-trans polyene structure in 2. These products are depicted as elongated dumbbell shapes with 5.4 nm in length in the inset of Fig. 1b. A Moiré pattern is observed due to the lattice mismatch between trans-polyene and the Cu substrate. For an individual molecule of 2, the polyene segment prefers to adsorbed on Cu chains along \([1\bar{1}0]\), with half of the phenyl groups aligning with the polyene trend (Supplementary Note 1 and Supplementary Fig. 2). This low-coordinated configuration enhances the possibilities for vertical manipulation of a single molecule 2 with STM tip in subsequent lifting-up procedures.To measure the single molecular conductance, we began by lifting up a molecule of 2. In the first step, after selecting an isolated chain based on a STM image, the STM tip was initially positioned at the phenyl moiety of 2 (the upper panel of Fig. 1c). Subsequently, the STM feedback loop was disabled. The tip apex was gently brought close to the selected chain until electronic contact was established, and then gradually retracted to lift it upward (the lower panel of Fig. 1c). Throughout the procedure, the variation of current with respect to vertical distance was recorded, as shown by the black and red curves in the middle panel of Fig. 1c. Both curves exhibit exponential decay (\(I={I}_{0}{{\rm{e}}}^{-\beta z}\), in which \(\beta\) is decay constant), but with distinct line shapes and decay constants. When the tip approaches, the decay constant of I(z) curve is 2.17 ± 014 \({\text{\AA}}^{-1}\). Based on the model of electrons tunneling through a one-dimensional potential barrier, it gives \(\beta=\frac{2\sqrt{2m\varPhi }}{\hslash }=1.02\sqrt{{\varPhi} ({\rm{eV}})}{\text{\AA}}^{-1}\), with \({\varPhi }\) represents the work function. We deduced work function of Cu(110) is approximately 4.45 eV, which closely matches the previously reported value of 4.5 eV reported in ref. 21. However, during the lifting of the molecular chain, a much smaller decay constant is observed, accompanied by oscillations.Conductance measurements based on reciprocating motionsTo gain a comprehensive understanding of the constructed surface-2-tip junction, we performed voltage-dependent conductance measurements (Fig. 2a). Previously, Grill and coworkers have done similar experiments on graphene nanoribbons via pulling several different ribbons under different bias voltage15. Here, we proposed an alternative method via the reciprocating movements (schematic depiction in Fig. 2a), where the same molecular chain was used during bias-dependent conductance measurements. In these “lift-up” and “bring-down” procedures, the same starting point is chosen for different bias voltage to ensure the same initial environment and coordination in continues measurements. Also, the same distance and the superposition of two corresponding I(z) curves guarantee the identical configurations in repeated reciprocating motion (Supplementary Fig. 3). During the “up and down” process, the phenyl groups significantly enhance the \(\pi\)-metal interaction at the tip-molecule interface, compared to pure trans-polyene. This leads to the stabilization of the entire molecular junction, enabling lateral manipulation and lifting of the entire molecule from the surface (Supplementary Fig. 4). Therefore, phenyl groups not only promote dehydrogenation reactions, but also stabilize this single-molecule junction.Fig. 2: Conductance measurements of a single molecular chain with different electron energies.a The conductance as a function of tip height in the same molecular junction with different bias voltage. Black, light blue, blue, light red and red curves are conductance obtained under 10, 20, 50, 100 and 200 mV, respectively. The inset is a schematic illustration of the reversable conductance measurements through reciprocating movement. The conductance curves exhibit exponential decay as the tip height increases, accompanied by periodic oscillations. These oscillations can be attributed to the lifting up of a (CH)2 group within 2, occurring at a periodicity of 285\(\pm 36\) pm which is averaged over eleven independent measurements in Supplementary Table 2. The black dash line corresponds to the exponential fitting of conductance curve under 10 mV, with a decay constant (\(\beta\) value) of 0.086 \({\text{\AA}}^{-1}\). b The averaged decay constant (\(\beta\)) obtained from analyzing eleven independent reversable conductance measurements (fitting more than 60 conductance curves). Decay constants of ten different bias voltages all fall within the range of 0.10\(\pm\)0.02 \({\text{\AA}}^{-1}\), with lower \(\beta\) values in negative bias voltages compared with positive voltages. The dash gray line points at 0.1 \({\text{\AA}}^{-1}\). The original data are shown in Supplementary Fig. 9a and Supplementary Table 2. Source data are provided as a Source Data file.Conductance measurements with different electron energiesFigure 2a displays the measured conductance during lifting up process under various bias voltage ranging from 10 to 200 mV. Taking the curve obtained under 10 mV as an example, we attempted to analyze the height-dependent conductance of polyene. The value of conductance exhibits an exponential decay with overlapped oscillations, a period of 252\(\pm \,\)4 pm. When taking more curves into considerations, the averaged period is 284.8 pm (Supplementary Table 2), which locates within the 12% deviations of the repeat distance of trans-polyene on Cu(110) (255 pm in Supplementary Fig. 2). It is a typical character of a low-voltage conductance curve and has been extensively discussed as lifting up one unit-cell of oligomer chain11,22. Therefore, the oscillation arises from the detachment of one (CH)2 unit in 2 from surface, without bias-dependence. This behavior is also captured in pure trans-polyene molecules (Supplementary Fig. 3) and different molecule-tip configurations (Supplementary Fig. 9a and Supplementary Table 2).Despite an increase in the tip-sample distance from 2.1 to 3 nm, the conductance measured on single molecule of 2 remains around \(3\times {10}^{-8}-{10}^{-7}\) S, which is the highest among the oligomer molecules or chains investigated, compared to 10−9 S in thiophene chain12, 10−10 S in polyfluorene11 and 10−8 S in (donor-acceptor-donor)n ((DAD)n) chain13. Also, this obtained conductance is much higher than the value of \({10}^{-9}\) S reported in break junction studies on carotenoid polyene23,24, and previous calculations in ref. 25. This high conductance remains relatively unaffected by varying voltage biases.Furthermore, fitting the conductance data with the formula \(G={G}_{0}{{\rm{e}}}^{-\beta z}\) provides further insights into charge transport in single molecule of 2 or a polyene chain. The obtained decay constant for a bias voltage of 10 mV is 0.086 ± 0.003\({\text{\AA}}^{-1}\), which is close to the detection limit due to mechanical noise. This low decay constant is also presented in Fig. 2b, with weak bias-dependence. All the averaged \(\beta\) values based on more than ten molecules fall within the range of 0.10\(\pm\)0.02 \({\text{\AA}}^{-1}\) for bias voltage ranging from −200 to +200 mV relative to the Fermi level, within the highest occupied molecular orbital and lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (HOMO-LUMO) gap of single molecule 2 (Supplementary Fig. 9a and Supplementary Table 2). Among them, the averaged \(\beta\) values are lower for negative bias and larger under positive voltage, which indicates the deviations in electronic state above and below Fermi level. Even though it presents bias-dependent, these decay constants are quite low compared with other oligomer wires: 0.4 \({\text{\AA}}^{-1}\) for thiophene chains12, 0.3 \({\text{\AA}}^{-1}\) for polyfluorene11, 0.23 \({\text{\AA}}^{-1}\) for (DAD)n chain13 and 0.17 \({\text{\AA}}^{-1}\) for another acceptor in (DAD)n chain26. Previous calculations gave a higher value 0.19 \({\text{\AA}}^{-1}\) by considering (LUMO-HOMO) gap and effective mass for tunneling electron25,27. In break-junction measurements of polyene-like molecules, β values of 0.22 \({\text{\AA}}^{-1}\)23,24, and 0.17 \({\text{\AA}}^{-1}\)28, have been reported, which are obviously higher than the one we obtained here. This low value of decay constant has been reported in measurements of polyene-like molecules with even number of carbons in oxidized state or polyenes with odd number of carbons in a symmetry configuration, where delocalized state on polyene was found28,29. As opposed to the solution environment in beak junction30, here is a simplified circumstance provided by low temperature and ultrahigh vacuum. As a result, it raises the question of whether trans-polyene chains in this case will retain their pristine characteristics or transform into a metallic state.Calculated conductance, charge transfer, and bond lengthTo gain a better understanding of the mechanism behind the high conductance and low decay constant obtained in single molecule of 2, transport simulations were carried out using the Atomistix Toolkit (ATK) package31,32. Figure 3a depicts the calculated conductance as a function of electrode distance, which corresponds to the number of carbon atoms in the polyene moiety, with the phenyl-electrode configuration in a planar geometry shown in the inset. This simplified device model yields high conductance and low decay constants for different bias voltages, qualitatively similar to the experimental observations. Taking the bending of single molecule during tip manipulation into consideration, calculations reproduced low decay constant, with the same value as we obtained from experiments (Supplementary Note 5 and Supplementary Fig. 8).Fig. 3: Calculated conductance, difference charge density and bond length.a Calculated conductance of diphenyl [n] conjugated polyene sandwiched between two copper electrodes, as a function of electrode distance (i.e., numbers of carbon atoms in polyene part of molecules (n)). The calculations are performed under bias voltage of 50 meV (blue dot), 100 mV (light red dot) and 200 mV (red dot), with exponential fittings shown as dash lines. The inset presents an example of model used in the calculations, where a single diphenyl [20] conjugated polyene molecule adsorbs on two electrodes via two phenyl groups. Circles color: bronze (copper), gray (carbon), white (hydrogen). b The difference charge density plot for the calculated transport model with diphenyl [20] conjugated polyene with side view and top view. The isosurface value is set as 0.05 e Å−1 at \(\pm\)0.005 a0−3. The symbol a0 represents the Bohr radius, and a0−3 is a unit of number density, indicating the number of entities per cubic Bohr radius. The arrows indicate the electrons transfer from C = C bonds to C-C bonds. c Structural and bond-length features of diphenyl [20] conjugated polyene. The structure of an individual diphenyl [20] conjugated polyene, its bond length alternation in gas phase and the fading bond length alternation in the calculated transport model are shown in order. Source data are provided as a Source Data file.To distinguish the contribution of different constituents, the conductance of a trans-polyene molecule without phenyl modification was calculated (Supplementary Fig. 5 and Supplementary Table 1). The influence of phenyl rings is minimal and can essentially be ignored. Therefore, the high conductance and low decay constant can be attributed to the polyene segment of 2. Earlier studies by Wang and coworkers reported a semiconductor-to-metal transition occurring upon the polyacetylene adsorption onto Cu(110), attributed to copper surface doping the polyacetylene with 0.1 electron per carbon atom19. Here, it was found an electron doping level of \(\approx\)0.42 electrons per diphenyl [20] conjugated polyene molecule, corresponding to \(\approx\)0.01 electron per carbon atom. This indicates a lightly doped polyene structure due to the partial decoupling in the lifting up process, which is dramatically different from polyacetylene on copper. Additionally, in Fig. 3b, it can be observed that the phenyl parts receive more charges from copper, further reducing the electron-doping level in the polyene segment. Consequently, the polyene segment remains semiconducting rather than becoming metallic.Despite the limited amount of transferred charge, it still induces electron redistribution within the polyene moiety. As indicated by arrows in Fig. 3b, electrons transfer from C = C bonds to C-C bonds, resulting in a more uniform electron density distribution across the entire polyene segment. The strong electron-phonon interaction leads to variation in bond length at the same time (Fig. 3c). In the case of an individual diphenyl [20] conjugated polyene molecule (similar to 2), the polyene part exhibits the Peierls bond length alternation with single bonds (1.42 \({\text{\AA}}\)) and double bonds (1.37 \({\text{\AA}}\)), which gets even larger during stretching (Supplementary Note 4). For the lightly-doped molecule in the calculation model, the discrepancy between the single and double C-C bonds diminishes, and they fall within the range of 1.39-1.41 \({\text{\AA}}\). This nearly uniform bond length distribution suggests that doping directly influences the bond order due to the electron-phonon coupling in polyene, which would affect the electronic state inside this molecular junction simultaneously.Fermi-level pinning and electron-phonon couplingEnergy-resolved measurement is crucial for exploring the high conductance and low decay constants. Figure 4a presents the scanning tunneling spectroscopy of tip-2-surface junction at a tip height of 2.2 nm. The differential conductance signal exhibits an increase around \(\pm \)800 mV, with some features shown at low bias voltage. A magnified view of these characteristics (Fig. 4a, inset) presents an electronic state at −20 mV. This feature around Fermi surface is captured by different tips with variations of peak position and intensity, with an averaged value locating at −23.4 mV (Supplementary Fig. 9b and Supplementary Table 3). Meanwhile, our calculations confirm the presence of an electronic state around Fermi level following the adsorption of molecules on copper electrodes, as shown in Fig. 4b and Supplementary Fig. 8b, which also works for single all-trans polyene molecule in Supplementary Fig. 5. The transmission state appears at 25 meV above the Fermi level, with minimal variation for different molecular lengths, a phenomenon termed as Fermi-level pinning33,34,35. The proposed explanation for it is shown in Fig. 4d, where LUMO of diphenyl [20] conjugated polyene aligns closely with the Fermi level of copper (Supplementary Note 2). In long molecular chains, the reductions of HOMO-LUMO gap create a compensating dipole moment to prevent the orbital from crossing the Fermi level. Also, this transmission eigenstate occupies the C-C single bonds, exhibiting a spatial distribution similar to the LUMO orbital of diphenyl [20] conjugated polyene (Supplementary Fig. 6). As a result, this frontier orbital dominates the charge-transport process in molecular chains, bringing it from out-of-resonant tunneling to on-resonant tunneling. It explains the decay constants for negative bias voltage is lower than those of positive bias. This is further confirmed when the pinning electronic state fades away in the height-dependent differential conductance measurements: the conductance drops fast when tip height is larger than 3 nm (Supplementary Fig. 10), indicating the on-resonant tunneling transforming to off-resonant tunneling. This is captured in calculations based on bended single molecule (Supplementary Fig. 8b), indicating the weakened contribution of molecule-electrode interface during molecular length increasing. Moreover, p states of phenyl groups can hybridize with d states of copper and create another coupling pathway for charge transport. It has been demonstrated that increasing the electron delocalization of terminal groups and the number of coupling electronic channels at the contact can enhance the coupling strength and reduce the contact resistance in molecular junctions36,37,38. Therefore, Fermi level pinning and the enhanced electronic coupling at the interface afford the larger conductance and lower decay constant. This highlights the pivotal role of the molecule-electrode interface in determining conductive properties in electric field.Fig. 4: Energy-resolved analysis for single chain.a Scanning tunneling spectroscopy (STS, black curve) and inelastic electron tunneling spectroscopy (IETS, gray curve) of single molecule of 2. The STS plot reveals an increasing electronic state around \(\pm \)800 mV, with a peak observed around zero energy. The inset displays the STS with a smaller voltage range with the corresponding IETS. The red shadow region marks the peak around −19 mV. Two signals in IETS indicate two vibrational modes, the stretching mode of C-C bonds at 135 meV and C = C bonds at 185 meV. More statistical data about STS and IETS are shown in Supplementary Fig. 9 and Supplementary Table 3. b The calculated projected density of states (DOS) of diphenyl [n] conjugated polyene sandwiched between two copper electrodes. It presents a pinned frontier orbital around zero energy for various molecular lengths. The purple arrow, orange arrow and brown arrow assign three peaks of a diphenyl [20] conjugated polyene molecule with specific molecular orbitals, which is similar for other molecules. c A schematic diagram of two vibrational modes of a diphenyl [20] conjugated polyene molecule in the calculation model. d Illustration of Fermi-level pinning formed at the molecular-electrode interface in this case. Blue and bronze regions mark the occupation of electron in molecular orbitals and copper electrode. Source data are provided as a Source Data file.Meanwhile, this pinned molecular orbital effectively improves the possibility of exciting the molecular vibration during tunneling, resulting in four step-like features in dI/dV measurement shown in Fig. 4a and Supplementary Fig. 9b–d. To magnify these vibrational signals, inelastic elastic tunneling spectroscopy (IETS) was carried out, revealing two centrosymmetric groups of peaks around 135 and 185 meV. These two modes correspond to the stretching vibrations of the backbone C-C and C = C bonds (Fig. 4c), which have also been observed in the calculated infrared spectroscopy of diphenyl [20] conjugated polyene molecules (Supplementary Fig. 7) and previous spectroscopic measurements of polyene39,40. Due to the high sensitivity of vibrational spectroscopy to chemical environments, the attenuated bond alternation weakens the stretching of C-C bonds and C = C bonds, as shown in Supplementary Fig. 7. The energies of these two modes are lower than those of an individual molecule, with the stretching vibration of C-C bonds decreased from 148 to 136 meV, and the stretching mode of C = C bonds reduced from 206 to 193 meV. These calculated energies closely match those obtained from IETS measurements (inset in Fig. 4a, Supplementary Fig. 9, 10), which are 135.6 meV for C-C bonds and 184.1 meV for C = C bonds shown in Supplementary Table 3, respectively. Additionally, these vibrational modes over the backbone of 2 open up new channels for charge transport by transferring energy to molecular vibrations during electron tunneling, which contributes to the highest conductance observed under a bias voltage of 200 mV, as shown in Fig. 2a. Although the appearance of inelastic signals stems from the strong electron-vibration coupling, the decay in conductance is predominantly governed by the molecular orbitals rather than the inelastic process. It is confirmed via the increasing decay constant during tip raising higher, along with reduced electronic state and inelastic signals (Supplementary Fig. 10). This explains the observation of similar decay constants for 200 mV and other bias voltages.

Hot Topics

Related Articles